Best Italian Restaurants in Cleveland

Mia Bella Restaurant has earned its stellar 4.5-star reputation from over 2,000 diners who appreciate its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone in your travel group. The impressive review count speaks to its consistency as a reliable neighborhood favorite that visitors can count on for a satisfying meal. With its mid-range pricing and location near University Circle, it's an ideal spot for a relaxed dinner after exploring Cleveland's cultural attractions.

This beloved Cleveland spot near University Circle has earned its stellar reputation with over 2,000 glowing reviews, drawing both locals and visitors with its welcoming trattoria atmosphere and diverse menu offerings. Diners consistently praise the quality and value at this moderately priced gem, making it a reliable choice whether you're exploring the nearby museums or looking for a satisfying neighborhood meal. Given its popularity, consider making a reservation during peak dinner hours to secure your spot at this crowd favorite.

Bruno's Ristorante & Catering has earned its stellar reputation among over 1,300 diners for delivering consistently satisfying Italian-American comfort food in a welcoming, neighborhood atmosphere. Travelers appreciate the generous portions and reliable quality that come at reasonable prices, making it a local favorite that's well worth seeking out in Cleveland's west side. For the best experience, arrive early during weekend evenings when this popular spot fills up quickly with both regulars and visitors in the know.

Perched on Cleveland's historic Superior Viaduct, Casa La Luna has won over more than 1,200 diners with its upscale bar experience and stunning setting that likely capitalizes on its unique elevated location. The impressive 4.6-star rating suggests consistently excellent cocktails, small plates, and atmosphere that make it worth the splurge-worthy pricing. Given its popularity and intimate bar setting, consider making a reservation for prime evening hours when you can best enjoy the ambiance and creative drink menu.

This beloved Cleveland bar has earned its stellar reputation with over a thousand glowing reviews, drawing locals and visitors alike to its welcoming atmosphere on Mayfield Road. The impressive 4.5-star rating speaks to consistently great service and a lively vibe that keeps people coming back. With moderate prices and a neighborhood feel, it's perfect for unwinding after exploring the nearby University Circle area – arrive during happy hour to experience it at its most energetic.

This upscale bar in Cleveland's Ohio City neighborhood has earned an impressive 4.6-star rating from nearly a thousand visitors who rave about its sophisticated cocktail program and inviting atmosphere. Travelers consistently praise the expertly crafted drinks and knowledgeable bartenders who elevate the experience beyond your typical watering hole. Arrive during happy hour to snag a seat at the bar where you can watch the mixologists work their magic, or settle into the stylish dining area for a more relaxed evening.

This beloved Cleveland establishment has earned its stellar 4.6-star rating from over 700 diners who appreciate its warm, authentic Italian atmosphere and consistently satisfying cuisine. Travelers rave about the welcoming service and generous portions that make it a reliable choice whether you're seeking a romantic dinner or casual meal with friends. With its moderate pricing and University Circle location, it's perfect for a pre-theater dinner or leisurely weekend lunch when you can fully savor the experience.